The Battle of the Mannings [Archive] - Assyrian

BONO

11-03-2005, 06:00 PM

I understand that Payton is at his prime. But if your are the coach of the Lions.. who would you choose.

Let the bidding begin... :alright:

NormieNorm115

11-03-2005, 07:14 PM

Well since Eli is only in his second year, and he's already producing, I'll have to with him. If I was coach of the Lions, he would be my #1 choice because we have such young talent around him and they're only gonna get better.

UmiSayz

11-03-2005, 09:00 PM

Yeh I agree with Normie. Hes already producing at a high level at only his 2nd season. I'd go with Eli.

Anonymous

11-05-2005, 01:12 AM

I would go with Jake Plummber...bcuz he is a much mobile QB..and he doesn't make stupid choices anymore..and he hasn't thrown a interception in a long long time and he will not shave that hair on his face lol..
no but I would pick Eli...just bcuz WE CANNOT FOR SOME ODD RESON BEAT THE FREAKIN COLTS IN THE PLAYOFFS...BUT THIS YEAR WE ARE GONNA TAKE IT ALL THE WAY BAY BEE.

UmiSayz

11-05-2005, 07:48 AM

I would go with Jake Plummber...bcuz he is a much mobile QB..and he doesn't make stupid choices anymore..and he hasn't thrown a interception in a long long time and he will not shave that hair on his face lol..
no but I would pick Eli...just bcuz WE CANNOT FOR SOME ODD RESON BEAT THE FREAKIN COLTS IN THE PLAYOFFS...BUT THIS YEAR WE ARE GONNA TAKE IT ALL THE WAY BAY BEE.

We're not talkin about Jake Plummer here and ELI is with the Giants not the Colts. You're probably thinkin of Peyton Manning.

Anonymous

11-05-2005, 01:26 PM

oooopz lol thats me ^^^mybad...I was eating and typing and u know...eating wins over typing lol

Anonymous

11-05-2005, 01:30 PM

I would go with Jake Plummber...bcuz he is a much mobile QB..and he doesn't make stupid choices anymore..and he hasn't thrown a interception in a long long time and he will not shave that hair on his face lol..
no but I would pick Eli...just bcuz WE CANNOT FOR SOME ODD RESON BEAT THE FREAKIN COLTS IN THE PLAYOFFS...BUT THIS YEAR WE ARE GONNA TAKE IT ALL THE WAY BAY BEE.

We're not talkin about Jake Plummer here and ELI is with the Giants not the Colts. You're probably thinkin of Peyton Manning.

I know who plays for who lol...i just mistyped...i was tlakin bout P manning and I would pick Eli intead cuz P manning and the Colts kill us in the play offs